Why Some Talented Footballers Fail: The Importance of Cultural Fit

Football transfers are often judged by talent and statistics, but success at a club depends on much more than ability. Cultural fit—how well a player adapts to their new environment—can be just as important as their skill level.

A player might struggle due to differences in playing style, language barriers, lifestyle changes, or even dressing room dynamics. When these factors are overlooked, even the most talented footballers can fail.

What Makes a Cultural Misfit in Football?

Cultural mismatches in football can happen for several reasons:

1. Playing Style Incompatibility

Every league has a distinct style of play. A player who thrives in a slow, tactical league like Serie A may struggle in the fast-paced, physical Premier League. Similarly, a possession-based midfielder may find it difficult to adapt to a counter-attacking team.

Example: Andriy Shevchenko was a world-class striker at AC Milan, but Chelsea’s direct and physical style under José Mourinho didn’t suit him.

2. Language and Communication Barriers

Football is a team game, and communication is key. If a player cannot understand the coach’s instructions or connect with teammates, their performance suffers. Even top players can struggle if they don’t speak the language of their new club.

Example: Juan Sebastián Verón excelled in Italy, where tactics and communication were clear to him, but he found it hard to adjust in England.

3. Lifestyle and Cultural Differences

Moving to a new country means adapting to a different way of life. Weather, food, and daily routines can impact a player’s happiness and performance. A player used to a warm climate might struggle in colder environments, and some may find it hard to adjust to a completely new culture.

Example: Luis Alberto moved from Spain to England as a young player but struggled with life in Liverpool and the demands of the Premier League.

4. Dressing Room and Club Culture

Every team has a unique dressing room dynamic. A player who was a key figure at one club might struggle to integrate into a new squad. Some clubs have tight-knit groups where outsiders take time to be accepted, while others have strong leadership structures that don’t accommodate certain personalities.

Example: Alexis Sánchez was Arsenal’s main man, but at Manchester United, he couldn’t find his place in the team’s hierarchy or playing style.

5. Expectations and Pressure

A record signing or high-profile transfer comes with pressure. If a player doesn’t perform well immediately, media criticism, fan expectations, and personal doubts can affect their confidence. Some players need time to settle, but modern football doesn’t always allow for that.

Example: Jordan Henderson’s move to Al-Ettifaq came with high expectations, but he struggled with both the footballing level and lifestyle in Saudi Arabia.

 

Five Players Who Struggled Due to Cultural Mismatches

1. Alexis Sánchez (Manchester United, 2018-2020)

After excelling at Arsenal, Sánchez moved to Manchester United in a high-profile transfer, but he never rediscovered his best form.

Why It Didn’t Work:

• United’s tactical setup was rigid, unlike Arsenal’s free-flowing attack.
• He struggled to adapt to a team that didn’t revolve around him.
• His confidence dropped after early poor performances.

What Happened Next?

Left for Inter Milan and showed flashes of his old self in a more familiar system.

2. Juan Sebastián Verón (Manchester United, 2001-2003)

A £28 million signing, Verón was one of the best midfielders in Serie A, but he struggled to adapt to English football.

Why It Didn’t Work:

• The Premier League’s fast-paced, physical nature didn’t suit his more methodical style.
• He struggled to adapt to Sir Alex Ferguson’s midfield demands.
• His best performances came in the Champions League, where the tempo was slower.

What Happened Next?

Moved back to Italy and regained his form at Inter Milan and later Estudiantes.

3. Andriy Shevchenko (Chelsea, 2006-2009)

A Ballon d’Or winner and one of Europe’s deadliest strikers, Shevchenko’s move to Chelsea was expected to be a success. Instead, it became one of the Premier League’s biggest disappointments.

Why It Didn’t Work:

• Chelsea’s direct, physical style didn’t suit his intelligent movement.
• He arrived at 29, past his peak years.
• Confidence issues and injuries limited his impact.

What Happened Next?

Returned to AC Milan but never fully regained his form.

4. Jordan Henderson (Al-Ettifaq, 2023-2024)

After years of success at Liverpool, Henderson made a controversial move to the Saudi Pro League, but it lasted just six months.

Why It Didn’t Work:

• The level of competition was far lower than what he was used to.
• He struggled to adapt to the lifestyle and football culture in Saudi Arabia.
• Reports suggested he was unhappy and wanted a return to European football.

What Happened Next?

Left Al-Ettifaq in January 2024 to join Ajax.

5. Luis Alberto (Liverpool, 2013-2016)

Signed as a promising young talent, Luis Alberto never adapted to English football and barely played for Liverpool.

Why It Didn’t Work:

• The Premier League’s fast, physical nature didn’t suit his creative, slower style.
• He struggled to settle in England at a young age.
• Brendan Rodgers preferred more dynamic midfielders, limiting his chances.

What Happened Next?

Moved to Lazio and became one of Serie A’s top playmakers.

Possible advice for Agents, Players and Clubs

• Scouting must go beyond talent.
• Clubs need to assess whether a player fits the team’s playing style and culture.
• Agents should consider a player’s personality and adaptability.
• Moving to a new country is a major challenge.
• Players must think about where they will thrive, not just chase big-money moves.

Football is full of players who struggle due to cultural mismatches. Success isn’t just about ability, and what a player has done at a former club —it’s about finding the right fit.

ABOUT SMG FOOTBALL

Sprint Management Global (SMG) are FIFA Licensed Football Agents representing players globally. A #FootballFirst philosophy drives our approach for our global football clients.

For further information on our football agent services offered by Sprint Management Global, please connect with us via email at info@sprintMG.com or call us at +44(0)20 8152 7665(WhatsApp).